Bates, Swan and Blaisdel pull off a much better team-up story for Superman, largely because the cover does not reveal everything.
There is a mystery villain behind this story, recruiting two very alien beings to attack Superman.
It’s a curious attack, that could expose his identity, but occurs in private. Though shot, he is not wounded. But he does start to emit sparks whenever he speaks.
Not sure what is going on, he asks Green Lantern to scan him with his ring. As the Lantern does so, the energy that caused the sparks emerges and kills Green Lantern.
And that had been Sinestro’s plan all along. Although his gloating over Green Lantern was none too wise. His cheme had been suspected, and the scan of Superman had been faked.
Aside from not showing him on the cover, Sinestro’s appearance is also unexpected, as he was just in the last issue. Sinestro returns the following year in the debut issue of Secret Society of Super-Villains.
Excellent art by Mike Grell on Maggin’s Green Arrow story in this issue.
He gets news that Black Canary has been killed, but the rest of this story is a flashback, leading up to this point, so the opening and closing are really the same.
Oliver and Dinah had been investigating a crime cartel with a mysterious boss. Black Canary decided to go undercover to infiltrate it. But the message announcing her death makes it clear that something has gone wrong.
The story continues in the next issue.